Each year I try to see as many of the nominated movies as I can before Oscar night. I typically start with all the movies in my three favorite categories—Best Picture, Best Original Screenplay, and Best Adapted Screenplay. This year I was able to see all but one (Inherent Vice). Since I haven’t seen that, I did not include it in my rankings.
1st Grand Budapest Hotel
2nd Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance)
3rd The Imitation Game
4th American Sniper
4th The Theory of Everything
I had a difficult time ranking this year’s nominees. The three movies I liked the best are, in my mind, equally good but for very different reasons. Boyhood blew me away. When I first heard about the project, I was intrigued but a little wary. Though I’m a fan of Linklater, I worried what direction the film would take. I was pleasantly surprised by the results, particularly the writing and Patricia Arquette’s performance. I also appreciated that the message of the film wasn’t heavy-handed, which was one of the problems I had with some of the other nominees. Despite the twelve year scope of the movie, it still manages to feel intimate and real.
Grand Budapest Hotel was an absolute joy. This movie was practically made for me. Quaint European setting? Check. Story framed by an author’s narration? Check. Impossibly gorgeous pastries? Check. As with all Wes Anderson movies, Grand Budapest Hotel is a feast for the eyes. However, it’s also a thoughtful, well-crafted story that’s a fun, creative ride from beginning to end.
I’m not a big fan of historical movies or biopics, and typically there is no shortage of these during award season. However, Selma was engaging and moving without feeling like a history lesson. It’s gripping and moving without being melodramatic. David Oyelowo’s performance is wonderful, and I, like many others, am shocked that he wasn’t nominated in the Best Actor category. Director Ava DuVernay also deserved a nomination. I don’t know what the Academy was thinking. However, despite its lack of recognition, Selma remains an important movie. It highlights the ideals that Martin Luther King, Jr. held and shows us how much farther we can go in seeing those through. Everyone should see this movie.
Birdman was good, but not quite as good as I thought it’d be. I think I built it up in my mind because of all the buzz. After my boyfriend and I watched this movie together, we spent a good hour discussing it—which is always a good sign. We discussed the elements we liked and the elements we didn’t like. We discussed what we thought the writers’ intentions were and whether or not we were interpreting them correctly. We even discussed what the writing process might have been like. After trying to decipher this movie, we couldn’t decide whether we liked it or not. Ryan concluded that it was a little to “artsy fartsy” for his taste. I determined that I did like it, with the proviso that I’ll need to watch it at least one more time. While I enjoyed the movie’s self-referential humor and its uniqueness, I couldn’t help but feel like the writers tried to do too much with it. I appreciate what they were trying to accomplish, but I’m not so sure they completely succeeded.
Whiplash was an intense but fascinating story. It follows a young drummer’s quest for success. Where most movies set in a prestigious conservatory would then bring in the inspiring, idealistic teacher, Whiplash brings a terrifying J.K. Simmons. At first, I took this movie as a sort of cautionary tale about the pursuit of perfection. But this story goes beyond that, especially in the dynamics between the characters.
The Imitation Game was a very interesting movie. Benedict Cumberbatch’s portrayal of Alan Turing was great, and I enjoyed the way they tied the story of Turing’s mission to crack the Enigma code with flashbacks to his youth. The story itself is rather incredible, and it still boggles my mind when I think about it. American Sniper and The Theory of Everything were just okay for me. I thought Bradley Cooper and Eddie Redmayne’s performances were commendable, but the movies themselves fell a little flat.
Best Adapted Screenplay:
2nd The Imitation Game
3rd American Sniper
3rd The Theory of Everything
N/A Inherent Vice
Because I was underwhelmed by American Sniper and The Theory of Everything, this category was much easier to rank. Whiplash was easily the winner for its intriguing narrative. The Imitation Game earned second place for the way its script connected the story of Turing's achievements with his past.
Best Original Screenplay:
1st Grand Budapest Hotel
Grand Budapest Hotel easily earned the top spot for its unique, hilarious script. Birdman, Boyhood, and Nightcrawler were all equally good—Birdman for its humor and sharpness, Boyhood for its well-crafted narrative and intimate feel, and Nightcrawler for its chilling take on the journalism motto “If it bleeds, it leads.” I found Foxcatcher a little uneven, so that bumped it to the bottom of my list.
- I wish Jake Gyllenhaal received a nomination for his work in Nightcrawler. I was surprised by his unexpectedly fantastic portrayal of sociopathic entrepreneur Louis Bloom.
- I absolutely love Amy Poehler’s Ask Her More campaign, which asks the red carpet interviewers to ask women more creative questions than “Who are you wearing?” I think it’s important to show young girls that these talented actresses are more than walking mannequins for designer dresses.